I am using a national dataset that employs a complex sampling design. I
understand the reasons for using software that accounts for the weighting and complex sampling design. However, I see that there are a few statistical packages available to assist with complex samples. I would like to use either SPSS Complex Samples or Stata. Is one package better, easier, etc. than the other? Thanks, Kristina |
There also is Westat's WesVar and SUDAAN
One point, IMHO, none is better than the other only a personal preference. Also, each handles the sample development slightly different. The SPSS module is fully integrated into SPSS and a great benefit if one's primary stat pack is SPSS. WesVar & SUDAAN are pretty much standalone. I have used WesVar for several years but know very little about the SUDAAN. W -----Original Message----- From: SPSSX(r) Discussion [mailto:[hidden email]] On Behalf Of Kristina Sent: Monday, July 10, 2006 7:53 PM To: [hidden email] Subject: Complex Samples - SPSS vs Stat I am using a national dataset that employs a complex sampling design. I understand the reasons for using software that accounts for the weighting and complex sampling design. However, I see that there are a few statistical packages available to assist with complex samples. I would like to use either SPSS Complex Samples or Stata. Is one package better, easier, etc. than the other? Thanks, Kristina
Will
Statistical Services ============ info.statman@earthlink.net http://home.earthlink.net/~z_statman/ ============ |
In reply to this post by Kristina-3
SUDAAN is A GREAT PACKAGE
>>> "Will Bailey [Statman]" <[hidden email]> 7/11/2006 8:27 AM >>> There also is Westat's WesVar and SUDAAN One point, IMHO, none is better than the other only a personal preference. Also, each handles the sample development slightly different. The SPSS module is fully integrated into SPSS and a great benefit if one's primary stat pack is SPSS. WesVar & SUDAAN are pretty much standalone. I have used WesVar for several years but know very little about the SUDAAN. W -----Original Message----- From: SPSSX(r) Discussion [mailto:[hidden email]] On Behalf Of Kristina Sent: Monday, July 10, 2006 7:53 PM To: [hidden email] Subject: Complex Samples - SPSS vs Stat I am using a national dataset that employs a complex sampling design. I understand the reasons for using software that accounts for the weighting and complex sampling design. However, I see that there are a few statistical packages available to assist with complex samples. I would like to use either SPSS Complex Samples or Stata. Is one package better, easier, etc. than the other? Thanks, Kristina |
In reply to this post by Kristina-3
SUDAAN was developed by the Research Triangle Institute, which is
surrounded by Duke, UNC, and NCSU. As such, SUDAAN is quite popular around that area of NC. WesVar directly competes with SUDAAN. I've used SUDAAN but not WesVar. I'd suspect that the only differences between these two packages which specialize in the analysis of complex and sometime multistage sampling survey data. In the 90s, neither SAS nor SPSS provided facilities for analyziing survey data. Now, both software packages perform analyses of survey data. Yet, they were never developed to specialize in the analysis of sample survey data. Whereas, SUDAAN and WesVar were. Since you probably don't have 1000 dollars to purchase SUDAAN or WesVar, I'd suggest that you use the SPSS add-on developed for that very purpose. Personally, I'm a SAS user, but have been forced to learn SPSS as part of my job. I hope this information proves helpful Joe Teitelman >>> "Will Bailey [Statman]" <[hidden email]> 7/11/2006 8:27 AM >>> There also is Westat's WesVar and SUDAAN One point, IMHO, none is better than the other only a personal preference. Also, each handles the sample development slightly different. The SPSS module is fully integrated into SPSS and a great benefit if one's primary stat pack is SPSS. WesVar & SUDAAN are pretty much standalone. I have used WesVar for several years but know very little about the SUDAAN. W -----Original Message----- From: SPSSX(r) Discussion [mailto:[hidden email]] On Behalf Of Kristina Sent: Monday, July 10, 2006 7:53 PM To: [hidden email] Subject: Complex Samples - SPSS vs Stat I am using a national dataset that employs a complex sampling design. I understand the reasons for using software that accounts for the weighting and complex sampling design. However, I see that there are a few statistical packages available to assist with complex samples. I would like to use either SPSS Complex Samples or Stata. Is one package better, easier, etc. than the other? Thanks, Kristina |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |